The Pittsburgh Penguins are facing a major goaltending dilemma, with Tristan Jarry ‘s poor performance casting a dark cloud over their season’s start. Despite signing a contract through 2027-28 at $5.25 million annually, Jarry’s current form, marked by a 5.47 GAA and .836 save percentage, has failed to justify his hefty salary. His inconsistency has left the Penguins stuck, as moving him via trade is nearly impossible due to his contract.

Head coach Mike Sullivan has continued to support Jarry, starting him on opening night and offering multiple chances for redemption. However, after a disastrous outing against the Buffalo Sabres, where Jarry allowed three goals on five shots and was pulled before the first period ended, his starting role is now in doubt. Sullivan’s patience seems to be waning, as Jarry was demoted to third-string status against the Winnipeg Jets.

Elliotte Friedman suggested the Penguins might carry three goalies while Jarry tries to regain form, but waivers are also a possibility. On the 32 Thoughts podcast, Friedman mentioned, “I wondered if they were going to put him on waivers over the weekend… it’s tough right now because he has struggled.”

Is It Time for the Penguins to Move on from Jarry?
Last season, Tristan Jarry lost the starting role to Alex Nedeljkovic, who nearly led the Penguins to a playoff spot with impressive play. Jarry’s current struggles, combined with a loss of confidence, have put Pittsburgh in a difficult position. As Josh Yohe of The Athletic noted, Jarry’s performances have been “unprofessional,” and there’s now open competition for the starting job between Jarry, Nedeljkovic, and prospect Joel Blomqvist.

Given Jarry’s contract, the Penguins are in a bind. Suggestions include a potential demotion to the minors or a buyout next summer, but unless Jarry shows significant improvement, a major decision on his future may be inevitable.